Opposition to the proposed changes

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I oppose the proposed changes in the 2022 MODEL POLICIES ON THE PRIVACY, DIGNITY, AND RESPECT FOR ALL STUDENTS AND PARENTS IN VIRGINIA’S PUBLIC SCHOOLS.  This policy is not about privacy, dignity, and respect for ALL in Virginia's public schools.  These proposed changes compromise school safety and erode trust in any caring culture from institutions that are intended to educate and uplift young minds and adults who commit to supporting and molding these students.  Public education is in a crisis and rather than welcoming people policies such as this one attempt to alienate them and push them away from public education.  Again, I opposed the proposed changes.     </p>


OPPOSE

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I will always vote to protect LGBTQIA+ members of our society. Strongly oppose this. If you're a concerned parent who "wants their rights" back, put your child in a private school or home school them. </p>


Support Parents Right

The school system is not a replacement for the parents or home. The original policies had language that created a wedge between parents and theirchild. We need more communication between the child and the parents, not a divisive barrier.

<!DOCTYPE html>

The school system is not a replacement for the parents or home. The original policies had language that created a wedge between parents and their
child. We need more communication between the child and the parents, not a divisive barrier.


Oppose!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Trans kids are in danger. The data does not support this policy and neither do I. LGBTQ kids are far more likely to face abuse, homelessness, depression and suicide. As educators and policy makers, it’s your job to support and protect our kids. This policy is embarrassing. </p>


100% Support Youngkin's Directive

<!DOCTYPE html>

It doesn't matter how many people comment about "transgender kids needing safe spaces," etc... the bottom line is that government schools CAN NOT and SHOULD NOT withhold information about a child from parents.  The transgender fad will eventually pass once a generation of children grows up and sues doctors and schools for talking them into horrific surgeries and sterilizing hormone treatments.  These children desperately need a dose of truth, not lies.  99% of these children are clearly going through a very hard phase and they need to be loved through it... not "lied" through it.  Thank you, Governor Youngkin for standing up for parents and for common sense.


Support Trans Youth & their rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>History shows that discrimating based on color, sex, sexual orientation just causes more hate & can lead to higher suicide rates. Trans Youth deserve to be treated like everyone else & we should be protecting youth instead of causing fear. All youth deserve to be protected, especially in schools where they have opportunities to learn that could change our world for the better. Do not move forward with something that is harmful to youth but to communities as a whole. </p>


Trans kids should be treated with respect. OPPOSE!

<!DOCTYPE html>

Trans kids deserve a safe learning envirotemnt


Youngkins Proposed Educational Policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

I support Governor Youngkins Policy, it’s time to focus on the educational needs of all children and students, sexual preferences belong on the personal side not in the classroom.


I oppose this policy change!

<!DOCTYPE html>

Our Loudoun County students and schools are not the forum for religious oppression and culture wars. These students need the freedom and safety to grow into their own personal identities.


a

<!DOCTYPE html>

If you really cared about the people you’re supposed to be representing, you would’ve never introduced this life-threatening bill in the first place!


S.U.P.P.O.R.T - to the moon and back!

Teachers, teach. Period.Parents, stay involved.  DO whatever it takes to get your kids to talk to you.  And love them.  Just love them all, through whatever they are dealing with.Kids, open books and learn to spell/count/think.  All too soon you will be adults and have to make decisions on your own.Government, back off.  (Thanks Governor Youngkin!  So glad I voted for your ticket and the three of you are serving VA so well ... you, LG WInsome - love her!) and AG Miyares)

<!DOCTYPE html>

Teachers, teach. Period.

Parents, stay involved.  DO whatever it takes to get your kids to talk to you.  And love them.  Just love them all, through whatever they are dealing with.

Kids, open books and learn to spell/count/think.  All too soon you will be adults and have to make decisions on your own.

Government, back off.  (Thanks Governor Youngkin!  So glad I voted for your ticket and the three of you are serving VA so well ... you, LG WInsome - love her!) and AG Miyares)


It takes courage to live your truth: Support Trans kids

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>adults are so insecure. so insecure that they attack the most vulnerable kids just because they are frightened by things they don't understand. Thank God trans kids can find support from their peers that understand Gods Truth: We love all of us. We don't judge. We support those in need. </p>


Support trans youth by supporting parents!

<!DOCTYPE html>

I support the changes Governor Youngkin made. Thank you for supporting parents to support their children. The school is not the parent!


Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly support Gov Youngkin's efforts to re-establish parental rights in our school systems.  I strongly support this bill.


transgender students

<!DOCTYPE html>

Transgender students should not get any special privileges or treated with special attention.  Keep them in their birth sexes.


YES I support new policy and guidelines

<!DOCTYPE html>

Limit government reach.  Release teachers from having to jump hurdles when they became teachers to TEACH.  Keep parents involved.  Any mean kid will be kept in line with good parental involvement and communication.  I hear of more abuse and bullying to cys kids who disagree than trans kids who want to feel safe.  Trans are so protected they and their supporters actually bully.  It's hypocritical.  It's inside-out.  Girls sports is in shambles and girls have been emotionally and physically assaulted when the don't want to share same changing areas.  Stop the madness.


Proposed policy violates my religious faith

<!DOCTYPE html>

My Unitarian Universalist faith affirms as its first principle the inherent worth and dignity of every person. The proposed policy on transgender students in Virginia schools violates that practical moral principle. Every transgender student is a natural person with the inalienable dignity of individual agency and a right to privacy which is denied them in this proposed policy. Each of these transgender person’s worth is inherent to their person, not residing in the mind of, or by force of, another person, even a parent. The policy treats transgender students as empty vessels without thought or self-awareness and completely subject to the control of parents in all things. This is plainly a dysfunctional and abusive family model, devoid of any recognition of the science of human development. This mistreatment of people in childhood results in adults who bring this dysfunction to societal interactions.  As a matter of conscience, I cannot support this morally reprehensible and wholly impractical policy. I am, in addition, compelled to resist its implementation and will support legal action to challenge the constitutionality of this policy which I believe to be in violation of the first and 14th amendments at a minimum. The DOE already well knows that portions of its proposed policy is at least unconstitutional under Grimm v Gloucester.

As a gay cis-gender male Virginian for more than 45 years I can speak from personal experience to the harm that policy proposals like this cause to individuals. I have endured the legal attack on my marriage to my husband of 37 years by the Commonwealth. It matters little that after years of litigation, these egregious offenses to the equality of some Virginians were eventually declared federally unconstitutional. The harm was done when the policy was proposed and implemented, and I can attest that it is long standing harm. Indeed, to this day, a vocal minority in the Commonwealth persist in hateful misinformation to attempt to restore the discrimination against my family.

I grieve today for transgender, non-binary, intersex and, indeed, for all LGBTQIA children in Virginia that, as children, they are called upon to deal with the harm of this proposal having been made and the inevitable hateful and dehumanizing public discourse that arises. If transgender students can be called out for punitive treatment under the guise of legal policy, any LGBTQIA student is exposed to a similar tactic, and they all realize this. I had trouble enough processing the hate directed toward me as an adult with a fully formed support network; I can not imagine the pain being experienced today by LGBTQIA youth who may be isolated not yet having found the words to describe their personhood. I grieve for supportive families of LGBTQIA children who are losing the assistance of their child’s school in navigating their way through this family dynamic.

The fact is that no Virginian was harmed by the existing policy for the respectful treatment of transgender students. In two years, no Virginian has managed to demonstrate legal standing to challenge the existing policy based in a real harm.  This proposed policy is already causing great harm and seems intended to do so. The moral path for the DOE, in my view, is to immediately rescind this proposal and to apologize to all those Virginians, whether children or adults, that they have harmed by publishing this proposed policy without consultation or apparent attention to ample evidence of the harm.

I will continue progress on the side of love in defense of the inherent worth and dignity of all people and in firm opposition to this proposed policy.


I STRONGLY OPPOSE these policy changes. Protect our trans kids!

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly oppose these rollbacks of the rights of trans children. Read what experts have to say about why this would be detrimental to their well-being. Listen to these kids and their parents.


Gov Youngkin's policies on Transgender changes

<!DOCTYPE html>

All children need protection!  Biological sexes need separate facilities, and teachers have the right to id them biologically.

Protect transgender youth with hostile parents by allowing them school counselor access.

Enforced compliance of name changes, etc  by non-transgender youth or punishment for non-compliance is contrary to religious freedom and negatively-affects THEIR mental health!


Trans kids are NOT bullied in school. Schools have rules against bullying.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I have worked in Virginia schools for decades and have never seen or heard of a trans kid being bullied. The schools would only need to enforce the rules if it did happen. </p>


I will always support trans youth.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I will always support trans youth.  No one has the right ti choose anything for someone else, not abortion or gender.  </p>


Youngkin’s policy regarding treatment of “transgender” students

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I strongly support Youngkin’s wise policy for students in Va. schools. </p>


Teachers, simply TEACH!  I support Governor Youngkin

My family loves to LEARN in school, not walk on eggshells

<!DOCTYPE html>

It's not about tolerance anymore, its about "all about trans kids" Teachers should be allowed simply teach.  Kids should be kids first - not sexual beings.  Trans have every opportunity other kids have.  Make school academic again.


OPPOSE!!!!!!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Strongly oppose this discriminatory bill! </p>


TRANS YOUTH SHOULDN’T BE DISCRIMINATED IN SCHOOL

<!DOCTYPE html>

Trans kids should not be discriminated in school. School should be a place where they need to feel safe. They need to be safe and protected like any other child in school.


Rights back to families

<!DOCTYPE html>

Give rights back to families


Protect Parents' Rights -- Strongly Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

Nothing in this bill is anti-trans.  There is nothing discriminatory.

Parents need to have the right to determine what is best for their child(ren,) and not some bureaucrats or school officials.  Parents need to have visibility as to what is going on with their child(ren.)

Women's and girl's rights need to be protected as well.  A biological male should absolutely not compete against biological females regardless of what they feel.  And, we have seen what happens when XX / XY share bathrooms/locker rooms (Loudoun County Public Schools, May 2021 and October 2021, same student: https://www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/us/2021/october/va-judge-finds-transgender-teen-guilty-of-sexual-assault-in-loudoun-county-high-school-girls-bathroom-case)  At an age prior to being able to understand long term consequences of their actions, we need to protect our children.

The wokeness has gone way too far and this needs to stop.

-Frustrated parent of three


OPPOSE, will always protect trans youth!

<!DOCTYPE html>

BYE RACISTS AND TRANSPHOBES! These kids will anyways be welcomed and loved by me


Hateful, sick people spamming comments OPPOSE

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I beg you not to count the support comments as they are bots. Leave trans kids alone. </p>


Overreach

<!DOCTYPE html>

This legislation is an overreach of the government. I strongly oppose these measures that are targeting an already fragile group of students.


OPPOSE

<!DOCTYPE html>

This will be detrimental to so many of our youths


STOP THE VIOLENCE FROM THE LEFT

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>America has seen first hand the violence that can occur from the left. Fairfax County is only one of several school districts in Virginia that have allowed the left to interfere with parental rights. Fortunately, our new state government has set into motion, policies that protect not only the parents rights, but our children's right to be children. Stop sexualizing our youth and help parents eradicate this blight. </p>


Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

Strongly support Youngkin's policies


Oppose, vulnerable LGBTQ YOUTH at risk


SUPPORT the new policies.

<!DOCTYPE html>

School is hard enough for young people without having to worry about members of the opposite biological sex in the restroom.


My Trans Child

<!DOCTYPE html>

My 12-year-old is transgender and just came out the last year. She has had a history of a suicide attempt due to being bullied in school. I had to homeschool her the year that she tried to commit suicide and then enrolled her into a new school to start over. In her current school she is referred to by her pronouns the children continue to bully her however now that she has received the help that she needed mental health wise she is able to handle the situation’s better so far. Other children that are not like her in the school system may not have the support of their parent. Our schools should protect our children whether they are the same as everyone else or a little bit different such as the transgender community. If teachers or staff are uncomfortable with referring to a child as their preferred pronoun because it goes against their religious preferences then they should simply just find another job because this is the new norm for this generation growing up they are empowered to be themselves. I do not expect for my child to be able to use the women’s bathroom because I respect people who do not agree for her to use the females bathroom around biological females. However my child cannot use the males bathroom because my child is transgender and anything could happen at that point. Luckily so far the teachers have been understanding and my child is able to use gender neutral restrooms and locker rooms. We need to protect our youth regardless of if people disagree with their choice it’s their life in the end and we should all be supporting them no matter what. Our trans youth deserve to feel loved and welcome especially in the school system.


Oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

Strongly oppose this policy. It places children in danger.


OPPOSE 100% protect lgbt youth


Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia’s Public Schools

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly OPPOSE; these policies would severely hurt transgender youth already at risk.


protect LGBTQ by INCLUDING parents, letting mom and dad be mom and dad - strongly support

<!DOCTYPE html>

Not the school or government role to make decisisons about my trans OR cys kid.  I SUPPORT


Trans kids NOT in danger! STOP THE LIE

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>The only danger our kids are in is the danger of living in the delusional world of gender dysphoria. Facts are facts and cannot be changed. Parents have a right to be involved in their children's lives until they are of legal age. </p>


I STRONGLY SUPPORT the guidance

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Those who oppose this don't want parents looped in if child doesn't want parents to know.  Those parents are not being given the opportunity they chose - to be a mom, to be a dad.  McAuliffe's policy ESPECIALLY HURT LOW INCOME FAMILIES who cant afford to pull their child out of public school and apply to private ones.  The low income families barely have time to participate in a forum like this one so I speak up for them.  The moms and dads who are too busy working two jobs just to get food on the table.  And now you self-righteous claiming "love for all" want to remove their rights to at least know what is happening for and to their child at school.  Don't say your fighting for love becoz love considers the good of the other person, not the self. </p>


OPPOSE, racist sickos get a job/life LGBTQ+ support

<!DOCTYPE html>

Trans kids are in danger! Hear us this is suicide prevention


This bill is a massive hypocrite

<!DOCTYPE html>

“All students have the right to attend school in an environment free from discrimination, harassment, or bullying.”

This was taken word for word from the 2022 model policy.

The 2022 model policy, which says that teachers should not only refuse to use students’ pronouns and preferred names, but go so far as to out said students to their parents.

If we have the right to attend school free of discrimination, why are you discriminating against us?

This model policy will not help anyone. This model policy will harm students. Studies show that having just one supporting adult in a trans student’s life can lower that student’s likelihood of suicide by 40%, and for many students, that supportive adult is a teacher. This bill would take those students’ support away.

“But parents’ rights-“ no. This is not about parents’ rights. Parents are in no way being harmed by their children’s identity. This is legislators using parents’ rights as a talking point to put a pretty little sparkly bow on their transphobia to make it look caring and sweet.

This bill is going to hurt people. Students, children, will be hurt because of this. Trans students take their own lives because they feel like they can’t be who they are. Trans students can get disowned because they can’t be they are. And this bill is saying that trans students can’t be who they are.

We are hurting, and you are rubbing salt in the wound.

Sincerely,

A Virginian transgender student.


Protect LGBT youth! Unsafe academic environment

<!DOCTYPE html>

Kids need a safe, fulfilling, comfortable enviroment


End the radical trans agendas of the educational establishment

<!DOCTYPE html>

It is time to remind teachers, education unions and radical extremists on school boards that they work for the residents of Virginia and are tasked with educating children.  Instead, these groups have focused on grooming and indoctrinating children against the will of the parents and often these agents hide critical information from those parents.

Schools can't administer and aspirin to children without parental consent.  The idea that schools can groom children and indoctrinate them in this fashion while hiding it from parents is abhorrent and ought to be illegal.

"Trans" children are confused or mentally ill children.  They need assistance and guidance from resources the parents deem acceptable.  This indoctrination has no place in schools.  It's time to remind "educators" of their actual responsibilities and empower parents as we raise our children.


Keep boys out of girls’s bathroom

<!DOCTYPE html>

Who are these people that want boys in the bathroom? Do they even have kids?


Thank you for parental rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>The newest fad of gender will ruin many lives before it's stopped. Children being mutilated, indoctrinated and trained to hate parents will destroy America. Please help parents rights to fight this evil from the left. </p>


OPPOSE- Trans kids are in danger

<!DOCTYPE html>

Trans kids are in danger


Trans kids are in danger


Strongly SUPPORT

<!DOCTYPE html>

My daughter was told she had to shut up several years ago during optional day of silence at her school, she HAD TO be silent to show support for the voiceless LGBTQ students.  Well since then she's been silent and the rest of the alphabet is screaming - not tolerance but acceptance and celebration and do back flips to make them happy.  They are not loving, they are cruel and vindictive.  If they don't get everything they want, if my daughter expresses any dscomfort she is called every horrible name they can think of.  She has been laughed at, mocked, and given such expressions of hate by students who claim THEY simply want to feel safe.  Yes, all must feel safe.  But it seems anyone who disagrees with programming in schools has no right to feel safe.  It's all about LBGTQ and some kids claim association just to not be bullied.  So wrong.  So thank you for correcting this error and bringing the protection back for ALL students.


Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

When people ask why has society gone downhill, a large portion of blame falls clearly on governmental interference. I support a smaller government and that includes control in schools


Trans trend shall pass - support policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This transgender trend amongst our kids will pass.  It is caused by indoctrination confusing our children!  Protect our daughters!  Please support new policy.  </p>


SUPPORT THIS CHANGE

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly support this change in policy. It sends to be a fair compromise. Minors deserve to have parental involvement. Parents have the right to be involved in their children's educational process.


Support this, thank you!

<!DOCTYPE html>

Thank you for following the science, the research, common sense and thinking of the good for ALL students and ALL parents.  Just this week in Vermont, 10 girls who appropriately expressed discomfort over comments a biological male said in the locker room (identifies as female, so gets to change clothes with the rest of the team, all biological females) were punished!  They play the sport with this kid, they just don't want to get undressed with him.  So the school closed the locker room!  Now 10 girls have to go one at a time into a one-person stall to change for practice.  This is topsy turvy and shows we need laws at the state level for common sense and decency for all.  As an educational aide I don't want the secrets and pressure placed on my shoulders.  Many co-workers don't either.  But we're the ones being punished if we speak out.  So we have no choice but be anonymous/use first name only.


These guidelines fail our children, and strangle our future.

<!DOCTYPE html>

Change is scary and intimidating at any age.  Every decent person, at some point in their life, has suffered the experience of changes outside of their control, and the lucky ones had community structure to make them feel like these changes were not a failure, flaw, or fault.  If we want our children to grow up to become better than us, then we should be laying the foundation to make that happen.  Academia is a sanctuary where children should feel safe with such changes, especially when they do not feel safe at home.  Stripping this safe haven from them will lead only to drastic pain, terror, abuse, and violence of both from body and mind.


I strongly oppose!

<!DOCTYPE html>

These new guidelines will do a great deal of harm. Trans kids who are just trying to make it through school alive and with some semblance of mental health still intact in a world that too often wants them dead are not the threat that conservatives make them out to be. You should be far more afraid of the people who want to restrict the rights of the already marginalized even further, so that they don't feel safe anywhere. They start with the marginalized, but they very rarely stop there. We need to oppose these guidelines now, before they get any worse!


I support this policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Parents have rights too. </p>


I oppose this bill!!

<!DOCTYPE html>

This will clearly do far more harm than any supposed good to transgender children in schools across the state. Enforcing things like this only serves to make our future generations more miserable and less functional individuals overall, which helps no one in the long run. The type of people that support this are the same ones that would abandon their very children if they identified as anything besides what they force them to, and refuse to learn and change to adapt to their child's needs, these are not the kind of people we should be listening to as they do not care about the well being of anyone else besides themselves.


OPPOSE - PROTECT TRANS YOUTH

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This policy only serves to alienate individuals who are nonbinary or trans. Forcing students to provide repetitive "proof" of identity only creates barriers to self expression and affirmation. These barriers are deadly for young people. </p>


OPPOSE!

<!DOCTYPE html>

Rights for all includes protecting our minorities. Do not turn back LGBTQ+ protections. To do so is harmful to the health and well-being of our children.


<!DOCTYPE html>

Please look out for the well-being, metal health, and protections for Trans and LGBTQIA+ students.  Young adults have enough to worry about without also being concerned with whether they are supported at school. For some, school is the ONLY safe space, the only place where they are listened to.  Removing protections imparts shame and embarrassment.  Please protect our kids.


Unethical and Anti-Parents!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>You say that this new proposal will give rights pack to parents, but it instead strips the rights of supportive parents of transgender students. Accepting people for who they want to be is a fundamental human responsibility, and getting away from transphobic policies is vital for this country to become a more perfect union. All parents deserve rights, not just liberal and not just conservative, so allowing students to be free to display their own values themselves without restriction is their human right! The LGBTQ community is here to stay and will not go silent. The faster we come together and choose love over hate, the faster we can start tackling the real issues with the Virginia education system, like teacher pay, academic achievement, and more. </p>


FROM A STUDENT: I AM AFRAID

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This policy is a hateful demonization of transgender students. Although the Governor would  like to guise this as giving parents rights, but really, you’re taking the freedoms away from people for being transgender, preventing them from being who they are. Why can’t the governor think about transgender students and their comfort and why can’t he think of his constituents, many of whom oppose this? Well we WILL NOT BE COMPLICIT, and our community opposes this and knows that our hearts in the right place, we love all, including those in the LGBTQ+ community ????? </p>


I OPPOSE the policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

As a student with many trans and genderqueer friends, the impact this policy will have on the school community is terrifying. By forcing teachers to out their students and disrespect their identities it turns school into an unsafe, threatening environment rather than a place of learning.


Strongly Support these new guidelines

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly support these new and updated guidelines. Parents know what is best for their children. Physical boys should not be in girls' lockerrooms, the same for girls in boys!! Parents what their children in a safe environment.


On trans rights


this policy is hurting students!!


Misgendering correlates with depression and suicide

<!DOCTYPE html>

I would like to start by asking a simple question;  how would the parent of a child know that child better than the child themselves?  Especially if the child is forced to keep secrets simply to not become homeless?  This is one reason everyone should be the one in charge of what pronouns and name they use.  Another reason is that the only person who can be seriously hurt by use of a name they didn't choose is the person whom that name is being used to refer to.  It has been shown that misgendering a trans person has major correlation to depression and suicidality (https://www.jahonline.org/article/S1054-139X(18)30335-5/fulltext links to and evaluates a study.)  If you would prefer a large increase in suicides among the teens of Virginia than their parents having less strict control over them, then this order does accomplish that.  Otherwise, this order goes against your goals for the people of Virginia.  This order needs to be repealed.


Support protecting kids from harmful leftist wokeness

<!DOCTYPE html>

Thank you governor Youngkin!


THIS POLICY IS NOT OK!

<!DOCTYPE html>

The Virginia 2022 model policy is not ok. It is harmful and discriminatory against trans, gender-nonconforming and nonbinary students. Making children feel like they are less then human is awful and it needs to stop. The way that Virginia has gone about empowering parents is harmful to students. Parents should know what is going on in their children's lives, but that doesn't mean they should be able to control or know every single one of their child's feelings, emotions, or thoughts. Children/Teens are often told that they are wrong or that their opinions don't matter. THIS IS NOT TRUE. Children/Teens are completely capable of making decisions for themselves and SHOULD be able to do so without parents controlling every single thing. Empowering parents DOES NOT have to mean making children feel unsafe at home.


I support legislation that prohibits people with penises from entering my daughters locker room.

<!DOCTYPE html>

Common sense legislation to combat reckless endangerment of our vulnerable children.


Support the Model Policy Keeps ALL Kids Safe

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>No this model policy won’t kill trans kids. It’s a lie they scream from the rooftops. Intentionally cutting parents out of a kids life with no evidence that a parent is a danger to a child is wrong.  Schools/teachers work with parents everyday with what their kids are dealing with. This should be no different. Schools/teachers should be providing resources not telling the child “it will be their secret”. My children know that if an adult says “it’s a secret between us” that adult is a pedophile and they should do whatever they can to get away from that person they are not safe. No one wants to change in locker room with the same sex let alone with with someone who is identifying as the opposite gender. It’s not safe and embarrassing for all.  Pedophiles and groomers try to remove parents and protections from kids regardless if they are doing it in the name of trans kids. Please keep this model policy and enforce it.  </p>


<!DOCTYPE html>

Regarding paragraph a1 of the proposed document. A school is a place for children to thrive. Especially not their parents if their doing so would inhibit the child’s well-being and mental health, this made even worse when that same parent is partaking in this way at home.


I Strongly Support Gov Youngkin's New Poicies on Transgender Issues

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly support Gov Youngkin's new policies regarding the transgender issues on bathroom usage and pronouns. He is supporting the rights of parents and protecting young people from confusion and these are the reasons he was voted in. Thank you for following through Governor Youngkin! Thank you for making some sense out of what has been an outright brainwashing assault on our young people. These monstrosities have been driven by certain people who want the world to go wierd and queer because they are confused or had been previously abused and it makes them feel better if others identify with their waywardness. Let our children go! Allow them to grow as God designed them to be...a boy or a girl! Brillant idea!


Support 100%

<!DOCTYPE html>

Hiding information from parents is simply not acceptable.  It is NOT the school system's responsibility to, in de facto, assume what is parental roles and decisions with respect to their children.


Strongly Support Youngkin’s Policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Without policies such as these, we are considering moving out of state to areas where there are more protective of parental rights. </p>


Protect our vulnerable youth

<!DOCTYPE html>

Growing up is hard to do, growing up questioning is even harder. As a grandmother of a questioning transgender youth I urge anyone that can, support changing the laws and to protect  these kids right to be who they are, to do so. Just because one may not agree with someone’s choice doesn’t mean it’s ok for others to not respect that choice.  I doubt any child grows up wanting to have to make the decision of who they are or what they like, especially in a tumultuous world. Imagine society telling you you can’t like something or someone. Forcing you to be someone you aren’t. Imagine not being allowed to eat your favorite food, wear your hair a certain way or like the things that make you happy. This is what we have to protect, a persons freedom of choice.  Please support!!

Silvia   Phoebus


Strongly Support!! Protect parents' rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

It seems ridiculous that we're even having this conversation. Seriously.
Finally, some common sense. Children are CHILDREN.

The encouragement and acceptance that adults are putting on children that they can "transition" to a different gender than the one they are born with...without having the parents/legal guardians in that loop is simply outrageous.

STRONGLY support parents' rights. Thank you, Gov. Youngkin!


Protect children's autonomy, protect trans rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

The US is a melting pot of different cultures. In order to remain respectful, it is important to refer to the chosen nickname the student chooses without the required parental permission. Not only does this allow the healthy development of identity, but it also bypasses any abusive, controlling or inconsiderate family structures that may otherwise impose their will on their child. Not every teacher can pronounce every name, students have been bullied over names, and a name is an extremely personal choice. A student should be allowed to request being called a name that they relate to, without the involvement of their parents. Regardless of beliefs, religion or moral code, it is unethical to force a person to be called a name or pronoun they are uncomfortable with, or one that creates dysphoria, anxiety, depression and so forth. If we truly care for our students, we will respect their bodily autonomy, as well as identity. During teenage years, children are developing an identity and sense of self for the first time. They are trying to learn their values, and figure out their identity. This is the safest period of a child's life to explore different names, identities, clothing styles, hair styles without it affecting their vocational status, since they are in school. Don't take away their autonomy, don't take away their exploration, don't take away their developmental right to figure out their identity, try new names, try new things. It's extremely important they be allowed to find what their authentic self feels like and is. A school is a place for learning, as well as encouraging diversity and self exploration through education, exploration and development. In order to create a safe environment that is the most conductive of learning, allow our children to voice their names and pronouns without parental consent, create gender neutral bathrooms or allow trans folks to use the bathroom that most aligns with them. Protect trans rights. If you truly care for diversity and the safety of your students, you will not impose these guidelines, and instead will listen to your students' voices regarding something as deeply personal as a name and pronoun without requiring parental permission.


Protect Trans/Non-Binary Kids

<!DOCTYPE html>

Younkin's policies are extremely harmful to trans kids, erases the existence of non-binary kids, and teaches kids that disrespect, rejection, and bullying is acceptable if you don't like how someone lives their life. These policies have nothing to do with protecting kids from trans kids but have everything to do with religious control. If parents have an issue with trans kids being respected in their public schools, they are more than welcome to send their kids to one of the many local segregation academies where hate speech and discrimination is the norm.


Strongly Oppose based on my faith

<!DOCTYPE html>

My faith asks that we treat everyone equally and with dignity. Youngkin's policies violate both precepts. I am not alone in this, as many have decried the inequality and harm that these "model policies" will cause to children and their families.

I am a parent. If you resepcted parent's rights, then you would listen to me and millions of others whose faith and morals guide them to love and respect everyone.


This is the wrong direction

<!DOCTYPE html>

Forcing a child to be called by their legal name in a guise of First Amendment Rights is not giving all students "the right to attend school in an environment free from discrimination, harassment, or bullying" as stated as one of the main objective in this 2022 proposal. It is also not supporting "efforts to protect and encourage respect for all students" because if the other students see teachers and administrators ignoring another student's wishes to be called a different name because they feel their First Amendment right allows them to be uncompassionate, the students will do the same without caring how it makes the person feel.

Research has shown that LGBTQ+ students experience higher levels of victimization because of their gender identity and/or gender expression and have more adverse outcomes compared to their cisgender and heterosexual peers (Human Rights Campaign Foundation, 2018):

?             73 percent of surveyed LGBTQ+ youth have experienced verbal threats because of their actual or perceived LGBTQ+ identity.

?             77 percent of surveyed LGBTQ+ youth report feeling depressed or down over the past week, and more than 70 percent report feelings of worthlessness and hopelessness in the past week.

?             95 percent of surveyed LGBTQ+ youth report trouble sleeping at night.


This policy is a form of bullying - and it puts at-risk kids in danger

<!DOCTYPE html>

This feels incredibly obvious.  Trans kids are at higher risk for depression, suicidal behavior, etc.  Trans kids are already bullied at an alarming rate. Some trans kids have supportive parents/family, but not all of them do. This policy targets trans kids for exclusion and state-sponsored bullying.  It will likely increase negative outcomes (including suicide) with absolutely no benefits.  It's an obvious political stunt that is designed to get the Governor on Fox News and help him do well in a Presidential primary. But it's a stunt that will harm real people.  You can't claim to be pro-life or pro-family if you support this policy - because this policy will cause trauma to families and potentially lead to life-ending outcomes.  Beyond issues of trans visibility/acceptance, this policy bullies kids - it may even kill kids.  And it shouldn't be hard to unite around protecting at-risk kids from bullying.


We are not going to discriminate against anyone.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Last time I checked, this is the land of the "free" and with that comes acceptance of ALLLLLLL sexualities and expressions of self. I don't have to and my country doesn't have to agree with everyone, but encroaching on freedoms and encouraging this type of hypocrisy is absolutely ridiculous. I oppose the govt having an opinion about abortion or any type of interest in who we choose to share physical love with....... </p>


Common sense

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Disregarding parents rights on how you want your children raised isn’t going to land you anywhere positive so back to the drawing board glad the 2021 model is out. </p>


Right Pronouns is suicide prevention!

<!DOCTYPE html>

I am a part of the LGBTQIA+ community as well as a Trans member, and many friends are also Trans and changed their pronouns. We are people just like you we love, we have bad days. But it means so much to have basic rights. Getting a legal name change can be hard and is timer consuming, and we need to be our preferred pronouns, some of us are not out to our parents yet, that takes time and is scary and not always possible. Please getting the right pronouns is so important it is suicide prevention.


Are you really “protecting the children”?

<!DOCTYPE html>

You probably think you are acting out of a sense that you are “protecting the children.” As a psychotherapist, I want to inform you that you are interfering in the vital expression of individuation, not only for trans kids but for their classmates who will likewise learn to abandon their own journeys of self-expression. Our communities are already suffering from depression and anxiety. Please don’t add to our suffering by intervening in children’s harmless, indeed life-giving, self-expression. For a party that prides itself on small government, you seem to let yourself run roughshod over the private lives of your citizens.


Strongly Oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

Kids know who they are inside better than anyone else, even parents. Kids have forever been allowed to choose whatever nickname they wanted in school, and should continue to do so, whether they have official paperwork or not.  This policy will harm kids when teachers refuse to use a child's chosen name / pronouns of their choice - AND it will put teachers in a terribly awkward position if they want to support the trans student and the policy says they cannot. This discriminatory policy gives the school system, teachers, and parents the right to be insensitive, judgmental, and hypocritical all at once. The department policy states: "each child is a unique individual with distinctive abilities and characteristics that should be valued and respected. All students have the right to attend school in an environment free from discrimination, harassment, or bullying."  Yet then the proposed policy goes on to discriminate by not allowing trans kids to be who they want to be. It prevents them from using their preferred name, pronouns, and bathroom of choice.  This hurtful policy will end up causing more anxiety, depression, and suicide among our (very small population) of trans  / nonbinary students.


Support Children & Youth to Learn and Grow without Discrimination

<!DOCTYPE html>

These policies are dangerous to transgender children and youth and will likely result in putting them at additional risk for deleterious physical and mental health outcomes -- even extending to suicide -- as not all parents are supportive and understanding of differences.  Please modify these policies to remove their discriminatory effects and instead put in place policies that will support all children and youth in being who they are, encouraging the use of bathrooms that correspond to their gender identity, and permitting them to reveal their gender identity to others (including their families) when they are prepared to do so.


Oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

This is disgusting and I vehemently oppose it. Do better.


Not every home is safe for a transgender child.

<!DOCTYPE html>

For many children, school acts as a safe place where they can be themselves without fear of their parents judgment. Some parents, such as those who support this bill, would not approve or allow their child to be their true self, whomever that may be. This will certainly lead to a decrease in their mental health, and cost lives. Every child deserves a place to be themselves, and if we take that away from them, it is on all of our hands that their blood will be spilt.


If you are suicidal then get mental health- not a new pronoun

<!DOCTYPE html>

Please kids. If you are reading this and feeling suicidal, then ask your parents or if you don’t feel comfortable then let a school counselor know that you need to see a doctor immediately. Adults in your lives that are telling you that a pronouns change will make it better are lying to you. They are accessing your deepest vulnerabilities for their own pleasure. Don’t allow yourselves to be manipulated by adults that don’t have your best interests at heart. Mental health is very important and will help you!


Clarify Language in Proposed Changes to Model Policies

<!DOCTYPE html>

In general, the proposed changes to the model policies on the treatment of transgender students are a step in the right direction. Schools should not be put in the middle of decisions that are rightfully made by parents and their under-age children. Plans for accommodations should be made in writing and agreed upon by children and their parents who have given thoughtful, serious consideration of their decision.

One point of confusion for the general public is the proposed statement about the use of bathrooms. The statement reads: "Students shall use bathrooms that correspond to his or her sex, except to the extent that federal law otherwise requires. See Grimm v. Gloucester County School Board, 972 F.3d 586 (2020).”  The media reports have left off that second underlined part referring to federal law and the Grimm case, which has caused confusion for the public. As you know, federal law prohibits schools from not letting transgender students use the bathroom corresponding to their gender identity. I urge you to consider clarifying that language in the final adopted guidance.  Without clearer language, an undue burden is placed on school divisions to explain to the public what federal law requires. While this may be politically expedient, it is not good governance.


Support ALL children! Support! Support! Support!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Take children out of politics and support all children. Equal respect for everyone. Pass the new policy! </p>


I oppose the anti trans draft policy!!!! Protect and respect our trans children!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I OPPOSE the draft policy written by Gov Youngkin and I want the VDOE to reject them. Protect our children! </p>


Reverse order to prevent death

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly oppose this order, and ask you to repeal it immediately. As the parent of a trans kid currently attending school in Virginia, I am intimately aware with all of the challenges these kids face. The last thing they need is to be attacked in new ways. This order does not protect our children, and will lead to the rise in suicide rates. That is not justifiable, even on religious  grounds. This is not a parents rights issue, this is not a religion issue, this is about protecting our children. They need to be the priority! The evidence is clear, affirming policies are the only thing that reduce the extremely high suicidality rates amongst trans students. Any policy that contradicts affirming trans students is an attack on the safety and well-being of children in Virginia, and should  be found unconstitutional. This order is immoral and cruel, and should be repealed immediately if you have any decency.


OPPOSE.  Stop discrimination against trans youth.

<!DOCTYPE html>

OPPOSE - stop discimination against trans children and their families.  All children deserve access to safe education where they are treated with respect.


Oppose! This does not make kids safer, only incites parent fears

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This revision proposed as “Model 2022” does not make kids safer. It is a cruel attempt to use trans and gender-nonconforming kids as pawns for a political agenda—and create a problem that harms the mental health of all our kids. Youngkin does not care about our kids—he only cares about political capital. </p>


Enough, leave trans kids alone!

<!DOCTYPE html>

I understand that pandering to the Republican base and stoking up fear has taken precedence over good governing, but just stop already.  These are children. I went through the public school system. There was no "grooming" or putting children in danger.  This recent fear mongering nonsense is straight out of a Tucker Carlson and Alex Jones tv show.  Seriously, you don't have anything better to do that will actually benefit all Virginians? Leave trans kids alone already. They have enough to deal with without their government dictating hate.


Support to stop discriminating against females

<!DOCTYPE html>

We need to stop discriminating against females. Females DESERVE the right to privacy, DESERVE our own bathrooms, and DESERVE our own sports teams. Thank you Youngkin.


PROTECT MY CHILD

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>As a parent of a transgender child, it troubles me that in 2022 we have a governor attempting to take away protections for a vulnerable population.  STOP making my child out to be less than any other child.  It is shameful.  Take the time to GET TO KNOW THESE CHILDREN!!  </p>


Please let honk about what you are doing

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I am a part of the LGBTQIA+ community as well as a Trans member, and many friends are also Trans and changed their pronouns. We are people just like you we love, we have bad days. But it means so much to have basic rights. Getting a legal name change can be hard and is timer consuming, and we need to be our preferred pronouns, some of us are not out to our parents yet, that takes time and is scary and not always possible. Please getting the right pronouns is so important it is suicide prevention.   </p>


Completely Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

I fully support this policy. No Federal, state, local government nor school boards, administrators or teachers own children and have no right to withhold information about minors from their legal guardians, be they biological, adoptive or court appointed. Parents and the people that provide their children with food, shelter, and relationships have the right to guide their child's development, have input into and approve of what they are taught in schools. School boards, administrator and teachers should be duty and legally bound to inform parents of any health, metal, or social issues related to their children.


Great job!  Common sense!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Makes perfect sense and is reasonable.  </p>


Support Trans Rights! Reject the 2022 Draft Model Policy!

<!DOCTYPE html>

I oppose this policy because it is rooted in transphobia, and seeks to impose harm on trans and nonbinary students. Trans affirming policies are beneficial to students across the gender spectrum. Almost half of LGBTQ youth seriously considered attempting suicide this past year, with 1 in 5 nonbinary & transgender youth making an attempt to end their life. These statistics are horrifying, and could be improved through supportive policies and practice.


<!DOCTYPE html>

This is sad. Stop using CHILDREN for rivalry and hatred in politics it’s despicable.


I oppose the proposed guidelines.

<!DOCTYPE html>

Please maintain the guidelines put in place under the prior administration, which had the best interest of children in mind. The same cannot be said of all parents.


Human Rights Violation

<!DOCTYPE html>

Any time we start to tell people they do not deserve rights because of who they are, we are crossing the line of human rights. Binary and trans humans are people and deserve the same protection as any other human being. Stop Youngkin's hateful bill and support human beings, please.


UNEQUIVOCAL SUPPORT FOR 2022 MODEL POLICIES ON THE PRIVACY, DIGNITY, AND RESPECT FOR ALL STUDENTS AN

<!DOCTYPE html>

I am writing to lend my unequivocal support to Governor Youngkin’s 2022 Model Policies on the Privacy, Dignity, and Respect for All Students and Parents in Virginia’s Public Schools. This is a document designed to take a fair, even-handed approach to the challenge of gender identity and sexuality in Virginia’s school system. This document protects the values, morals, and ideologies held by many traditional families, while also respecting the needs demonstrated by families who have children with gender identity issues (many of which look different in their varied approach and response to this relatively novel issue). As stated in the beginning of the document: “The Code of Virginia reaffirms the rights of parents to determine how their children will be raised and educated. Empowering parents is not only a fundamental right, but it is essential to improving outcomes for all children in Virginia.” This document rightfully replaces the overreaching parental authority so dubiously usurped under former Governor Northam.

The 2022 Model Policy protects constitutional rights to free speech and freedom of religion by placing the issues of gender identity and sexuality firmly within the appropriate boundaries of the family unit, thereby ensuring the government (as representative of the federal DOE, state DOE, and local school board and Superintendent) does not have undue authority over our children. The former policy compelled speech, which is illegal under the U.S. Constitution. Northam’s policy resulted in punitive consequences for students or teachers accused of “mis-gendering,” “using incorrect pronouns,” or “dead-naming” others. The school system has no authority to compel speech, nor can it undermine the freedom of religion under which most families are instilling values and morals unaligned with the latest trends promoted by career politicians and ideologues.

Northam’s previous policy pitted parents against the school system and its institutions. The starting point for conversations regarding these issues is that parents are unaccepting, or worse, abusive—the implication being that any parent who doesn’t celebrate their child changing their gender identity or welcome it with open arms is not compassionate or caring, and even verging on abusive (though I suspect that even the most affirming parents would pursue therapy to ensure the safety of their child based on some of the self-harm behaviors that tend to accompany these issues and perhaps may even go through a challenging time adjusting to these changes). The other implication is that the schools are better equipped with the education, knowledge, and experience to deal with these issues than families. I reject this starting premise, and quite frankly, I find it extremely insulting. As parents, we cannot advocate or seek the proper care and treatment for our children if we aren’t even given the opportunity to do so because the schools are keeping secrets.

I can imagine how frustrated I might be as a parent to go into a school and realize that my child’s teachers and peers have been calling him/her by a different name and/or using different pronouns before I may have even had a chance to seek a therapist or psychiatrist to address this issue and/or other tangential issues of self-harm or suicidal ideation that may also be accompanying this confusion. It’s frustrating because often educators do not know the entire context of that child’s issues, and they are getting involved in matters that may be way more complex than what they know. Teachers (who are not certified in psychology) may insist on gender affirmation even if in a particular child’s case that may be detrimental to his/her treatment. One size doesn’t fit all, and one approach is not effective for every child. That child may already be seeing a professional whose treatment methods may not be consistent with what teachers are promoting and may, in fact, be counterproductive to the path deemed most effective by an expert to promote the best interests of a child. It seems to me that a policy that encourages partnerships between parents and schools—more dialogue, more consistency, and more support in a child’s life—is better able to address a child’s welfare. Consequently, this is not about parents denying help for their children or being unsupportive, this is about parents being aware of all issues concerning their children. Oftentimes, parents are actually supportive, but regardless, parents need to be aware and actively involved in these issues. I would urge that this administration continue to uphold a parent’s rights and responsibility to address their own child’s issues, mental health or otherwise. It is imperative for parents in these situations to understand what is going on with their children and to get to the bottom of any underlying issues that may causing problems.

This policy protects teachers from overstepping boundaries that are safeguarded by the law. Many families who are experiencing these issues are already seeking out qualified therapists/psychologists and doctors for the treatment of gender identity issues. There is a lack of qualification and accreditation on the part of teachers with which parents are uncomfortable. Unless parents have given specific instruction or permission to talk openly with their child about these issues, this is a boundary that quite necessarily could be legally enforced but it is also one in which a parent should have a reasonable expectation that the school would respect. These discussions and decisions rightfully belong between parents, therapists, and the child’s doctors and not a teacher or administrator who is not a certified psychologist or psychiatrist. It doesn’t make sense to me or sit well as a parent for the schools to be calling children by different names or using different pronouns without the minimum of parental knowledge and subsequent consent. Teachers are not certified psychiatrists or therapists, and they should not be engaging in gender affirmation as if they know what is best without guidance from a trained professional or explicit instruction from a parent. The schools contend that they want parent involvement but at the same time they shut parents out of the most fundamental, perhaps life-altering, matters in a child’s life.

The counter argument to implementing policies like this is always a concern about the child’s safety and well-being at home. I would like to see the statistics regarding children who face harm or violence for coming out as transgender (and I would want to see research establishing a causal relationship between confiding in parents and not merely statistics regarding abuse or harm among children dealing with these issues). I suspect that those who would fear a harmful or violent reaction already come from dysfunctional homes, which may or may not already have authorities involved in the situation. Unfortunately, we do not get to decide how other people raise their children. It is simply not the school’s role to determine which families will be accepting or to determine whether or not a family is being accepting because acceptance is subjectively defined; defining this for a parent essentially amounts to a profiling of families and an attempt by the schools to impose their own values on others with whom they may not agree. It is important to remember that care and compassion do not always take the form of endorsing behaviors. To imply that a family that is not gender affirming is somehow complicit or evocative of self-harm or suicidal ideation to their own child is a very weighty, and even hateful, message to send to parents who may already be dealing with difficult issues in their child’s lives. When it comes to the ideas of support for children, this will look different for every family. I might nurture my child's self-esteem by validating the truth that they have certain characteristic and identity traits that were God-given and made in His image, whereas another might judge that this is not a validation of self-esteem to a child with gender identity issues. I think we have to use EXTREME CAUTION determining who, how, and what these standards become. Otherwise, the school/administrators/teachers have far too much leeway and flexibility in judging parents' abilities to meet these expectations. Just as it would not be right for me to decide how another family chooses to respond to their child's issues/crises, it is not ok for the school or other parents to decide what is right for my child.

I firmly believe and will continue to argue that discussions regarding gender identity and a child’s struggle with their gender or their sexuality is a discussion that should be handled in the family unit, and the government (and by extension schools) should not interfere with these intimate and personal issues. Just as a school would have an obligation to communicate to a parent or guardian if a child were experiencing depression, engaging in risky behavior, considering suicide, or demonstrating addictive personality or behaviors, parents should be informed of all substantive issues regarding their children, good or bad. I would assume that it is still the responsibility of the parent to address any and all of these issues should they arise, so I am unsure why issues regarding gender identity are an exception to the rule.


Stop the hate

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This policy puts LGBTQ students at risk for bullying and suicide. Did you know that trans youth are more likely to attempt suicide if they don’t have supportive adults in their lives? For some students, school is their ONLY safe space. This is why teachers are mandated reporters of abuse—because telling parents isn’t always the safe thing to do. Also, doesn’t Virginia lose federal funding for schools if we roll back protections for trans kids? So then all students are punished because of your hatred for one group. Please think about who you are really trying to protect. It isn’t children.As a healthcare provider who works with the LGBTQ community, this is NOT the solution. </p>


<!DOCTYPE html>

Virginia Department of Education

Superintendent Jillian Balow

James Monroe Bldg., 25th Floor

101 N. 14th St.

Richmond, VA 23219

Re: AAUW-VA Comment on the Proposed 2022 Model Policies on the Privacy, Dignity, and Respect for All Students in Virginia’s Public Schools

When the Virginia legislature adopted legislation in 2020 that required the Department of Education to provide school boards with model policies to support young students as they navigate the complex path to establishing their personal identity, AAUW of VA and its members applauded the protection of transgendered students’ rights.  Model policies issued in 2021 after the legislation provided clear guidelines for local school boards to follow in establishing local policy.

The new model policies issued by the Virginia Department of Education clearly contradict the intention of the legislature in passing the original bill, which will only serve to confuse both school districts and individual educators.  In addition, many legal scholars have stated that the proposed policy would require districts and teachers to violate Federal and Virginia law. Both the divergence from the original statutory intent of the legislature and the conflict with existing legal principles will lead to ongoing litigation, the cost of which will divert critically needed education dollars from the classroom.

From preschool?through high school, most children encounter?some degree of “gender tracking”—stereotypes?and?expectations?that can set them on a lifelong path.??Gender tracking in early education explains why so many professions continue to be highly gendered, with women disproportionately in lower-paying fields.

While these stereotypes inhibit all students from being their authentic self, transgender and gender-nonconforming students suffer even more, as many schools are ill-equipped to accommodate students outside the gender binary.

AAUW supports public education that promotes gender fairness, equity, and diversity, including vigorous enforcement of Title IX and all other civil rights laws pertaining to education and the enforcement of such laws. Therefore, we urge the Department of Education to revise the proposed guidelines to conform with the original intent of the legislature and to comply with Federal law.

Respectfully submitted,

Janine Greenwood and Denise Murden

Co-VPs for Public Policy

AAUW-VA


Support- it isn’t all about you. Get over it.

<!DOCTYPE html>

Life isn’t always fair. You don’t always get what you want. I’m sorry that your parents never taught you that. Life has rules. You don’t get to change the English language. You don’t get to shower with little girls. Life goes on.


Opposed

<!DOCTYPE html>

I oppose this discriminatory policy


Support common sense initiative to protect females

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Thank you Youngkin. Evidently, these people against your legislation don’t have girls. Anyone with a child understands that it is inappropriate for boys to be in locker rooms, shower facilities, and bathrooms of girls at this age. </p>


Reject a policy that will do harm to VA youth

<!DOCTYPE html>

These policies will take away a safe space for already vulnerable youth. For some youth, this is their only safe space. These policies will not simply take away a safe space, but also create a hostile environment for transgender youth, empowering bullying peers and teachers to victimize youth who are already at elevated risk for victimization. Not all homes are safe, as we know from the high rates of domestic violence and child abuse. Rates of depression, suicidality, and suicide are alarmingly high among transgender youth. Having a safe school environment, where children can be themselves and are supported in their identities, however, is associated with better mental health (less depression, less suicidality, fewer suicides). Nothing less than the mental health -- and indeed the very lives -- of the young people of VA are at stake.


An FCPS parent

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p style="text-align: left;">Governor Youngkins’s proposed model policy is rooted in transphobia, seeks to erase trans and nonbinary youth from the classroom, and creates a hostile school environment. It is my hope that the VDOE will OPPOSE and reject the draft policy. </p>


Model Policies for the Treatment of Transgender Students in Virginia’s Public Schools

<!DOCTYPE html>

Governor Youngkin's proposed policy re: transgender students is a blatant attempt to promote his political career at the expense of children's wellbeing.

As the parent of five kids in Virginia public schools (3rd grade-college), I am deeply opposed to this policy proposal. It is needlessly cruel. Please stop trying to stir up controversy and focus on improving educational outcomes for all Virginia kids.


Please protect all kids INCLUDING those who identify differently

<!DOCTYPE html>

As a teacher I see the fear mongering that’s happening with some of the proposed changes. All students need to feel safe at school. We are not making extraordinary accommodations for any students currently. I’m not sure why all of a sudden this has become an issue for this administration. It saddens me, I’ve worked with social work and kids for over 40 years And I really felt Virginia was in a good place for education and protecting our students. Please don’t prove me wrong.


Va Department of Ed Transgender Policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

Thank you for the new policy.  I strongly support the new policy that provides protection to all students and gives girls an opportunity to play sports on a level playing field.


Strongly Support


Stop the Bigotry - Protect the Civil Rights of Transgendered Children

<!DOCTYPE html>

This is a civil rights issue. Families are afraid of things they don't understand. A transgender child should have rights just as much as a cisgender child. For those conservative folks, you can't "turn transgender" just like you can't "turn gay." You are either that way or not. Love all. Isn't that the Christian way? That includes respect.

Someone who practices Christianity has the right to say a prayer during their lunchtime and not be ostracized for who they are - a Christian. A transgender child has the right to feel welcomed and included too. How would you feel if you were told you can't be who you are, you can't be Christian? What if you were forced to say a Muslim prayer and made to feel uncomfortable? That's abusive.

When someone is not allowed to be addressed as the gender they know psychologically they are or they are not allowed to use a bathroom that they feel comfortable going into - that's abusive too.

I am a licensed psychotherapist and have worked with adolescents and families, including transgender clients, conservative clients, liberal clients, and moderates. The amount of pain and suffering that marginalized people experience is unknown for those from the dominant culture - Christian, White, etc. You have no idea and if you have been oppressed - empathize with the transgender youth. Please stop your bigotry and prejudice because that is what our governor is being with this. Protect ALL children by allowing respect, differences, and accommodations. This is a civil rights issue.

With care,

Yvette

Yvette Coronado Mercer, LMFT


Support Governor Youngkins  changes in  Trans Policy Guidance

First of all, I applaud Governor Youngkin’s dismantling
the policies that were set in place by the previous  administration.We say that common sense tells us to protect the hearts,
minds and bodies of our children-all of them!  To think that educators
would embrace helping a student “ deceive” their parents, or even
allow students to “ demand” using  language ( pronouns) that flies
in the face of reality is confusing at best. I say keep going Governor Youngkin
with common sense policies - let’s disrupt, dismantle and destroy this confusion
that is meant to indoctrinate - divide and rob our children of an education.

<!DOCTYPE html>

First of all, I applaud Governor Youngkin’s dismantling

the policies that were set in place by the previous  administration.
We say that common sense tells us to protect the hearts,

minds and bodies of our children-all of them!  To think that educators

would embrace helping a student “ deceive” their parents, or even

allow students to “ demand” using  language ( pronouns) that flies

in the face of reality is confusing at best. I say keep going Governor Youngkin

with common sense policies - let’s disrupt, dismantle and destroy this confusion

that is meant to indoctrinate - divide and rob our children of an education.


Having power over one's body is important.

<!DOCTYPE html>

     It is important for others to accept the way that people want to be treated.  If one is terribly uncomfortable with one's body, one can change things about it, now thanks to science, even one's own gender.

      The "it is against nature" argument does not stop us from other things.  Gravity pulls us down, and yet we stand up.  We have eyes that don't see well, and so we wear glasses.

     Differences are parts of the beauty of our world.  Changes and differences in others may make us uncomfortable sometimes, but it is healthy to recognize that human beauty and love can come in many forms.

     Please don't discriminate against people who just want to feel comfortable in their own bodies.


Strong Opposition

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I am writing in opposition to the governor's proposed anti-trans policies. These policies aim to make a teacher's job of working with young children and teenagers, an already difficult, emotional, and under-appreciated job, even more difficult by policing how teachers may and may not support their students, and especially targeting students who may need that support the most. These policies target children, which is never appropriate no matter the case. They allow for some children to be singled out, reprimanded, or otherwise punished for being themselves. I sincerely hope the administration can reconsider these policies and does not create undo harm in our public schools that are already struggling with so many challenges, including under-funding. </p>


STRONGLY OPPOSE, Stop harassing people just because you don't agree with them.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Stop putting children in dangerous situations. If you agree to this as a parent of a transgender child, then you know why your child doesn't feel safe and loved at home. </p>


Opposed to fear-based political stunts

<!DOCTYPE html>

As the parent of a non-binary teen and the aunt of a trans adult, I strongly oppose fear-based politics and political stunts--and that's all this is. Why is Gov. Youngkin putting time, effort, and energy into opposing fundamental human rights for trans youth instead of supporting stronger schools for ALL students? The politics of us versus them are hateful and harmful. This is nothing more than a political stunt. As for the battle cry of "parents' rights," let me ask you this: What about the rights of parents who want their trans students fully supported at school? Please put myself and my husband down as opposed to this horrible policy.


I strongly oppose this from Youngkin

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Youngkin is wrong. He has an agenda. He is NOT "pro life". He is pro in-vitro. After birth, he couldn't care less for children. Oppose this bill! </p>


OPPOSE

Virginians for Minding Your Own Damn Business

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly oppose these governmental guidelines. They endanger vulnerable children without a support system in the home.


Freedom of Expression

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>The Constitution supports freedom of expression. And discrimination is unlawful at least for today. Be strong. Keep Virginia part of the land of the free. Thank you. </p>


OPPOSE

<!DOCTYPE html>

As a social worker in VA, I strongly oppose Youngkin's proposed policy changes to trans kids rights. I have worked with children as young as in 1st grade who identify as transgender and have tried helping them feel confident and comfortable with who they are. They are not hurting anyone. They're simply being themselves.

Not using pronouns that the child prefers is nothing but disrespectful. Forcing schools to "out" gay and transgender students is harmful to their psyche and could put them in physical danger, not only at school but at home as well. It could also increase suicidal ideation and/or the number of suicide attempts if these kids feel completely alone and unsupported. It can affect their mental health, their grades, their participation in clubs, sports, and other activities. School should be a safe haven for children but this policy takes that right away from kids.

Youngkin is saying this is a parental rights issue yet it's completely disregarding parents of trans kids who actually support their children. These parents love, accept, and respect their children to the fullest and trust their children to be who they are. It does nothing to protect parent's rights, kid's rights, or anyone's rights. It's just another hateful way of discriminating against the LGBTQ community.

Youngkin's policy changes are transphobic and do nothing except look to harm trans kids. He is using children as a political pawn rather than letting human beings live as they wish and be happy as they are. Oppressing children's rights is despicable and I stand firmly against it. To be clear, I OPPOSE the draft policy and want the VDOE to reject Youngkin's changes.


Oppose this hateful bill

<!DOCTYPE html>

In what world is this protecting children? The only thing this accomplishes is further deaths of trans children


Approve - Parents want what's best for their child.

<!DOCTYPE html>

Mostly agree with new model. Parents should have 100% knowledge and participation with their child's happenings. And ALL kids should feel safe and cared for, not just one group. Keep up the good work Governor Youngkin!


Reminder of the first amendment. Freedom of expression.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>In the first amendment it says ALL US citizens have the right to freedom of speech, religion,expression, and assembly. Now to my knowledge this means that despite you or my beliefs if a woman wants to express themselves as a man they have every right to do so. There are arguments that trans men and woman are just people with mental illnesses, but how many men and women struggle with mental illness and hold upstanding lives without harming others? This is simply about people who are trying to live their lives in a way that make them happy and comfortable. This isn’t about people preying on children or taking away parental rights. It’s one man taking away a whole communities rights to change and express themselves how they want to in order to be happy and whole in their lives. </p>


Opposition to Guidance

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I oppose this guidance. Despite Gov. Youngkin’s insistence that the purpose of this guidance remains the same, to prevent discrimination, it will do the exact opposite of that. Trans students know themselves best and should have the option to change their names and pronouns and have them be respected without parental interference. Many students sadly do not have supportive environments at home and it is shameful that this guidance would pit these students’ teachers against them. As an ally to the LGBTQ community I find this proposed guidance an unnecessary and harmful move as it will do nothing to further protect this vulnerable group. </p>


Heartily oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

This proposed policy is cruel, disrespectful of others and divisive. Shame on you!


Strongly oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

The 2021 Model Guidance was comprehensive in supporting trans/nonbinary students in a manner designed to support their mental health and well-being, and it should remain in effect. The 2022 Model Guidance reverts to lip service of "accommodating" these most at-risk of students, while prioritizing parental rights and control over student mental health and well-being. These policies have LIFE OR DEATH consequences. In loving memory of Aiden E. York, of Lovettsville VA.


Support the proposed policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

I have read the proposal and strongly agree with the recommendations.  I believe parents should be included in decisions regarding their underage child.  I also believe the transgender child should be treated with respect and not be submitted to bullying.  The proposed policy takes into account the rights of all and strikes a balance which I can support.


Strongly oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Please protect trans and non-binary students in Virginia. They are more vulnerable than cisgender kids. They all deserve the same respect in school; isn’t this what the Constitution is for?? Oppose Youngkins new bigoted policy. </p>


Support! Stop Being Useful Idiots In This Larger Agenda

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>This is just another way to destroy lives! Destroy these children! Destroy America!! </p>


In support of new draft guidelines!

<!DOCTYPE html>

The new guidelines from the new Governor are a refreshing step in support of parents’ rights. They are not anti- any group of individuals and can still be implemented with empathy and kindness. Let’s move forward with these new guidelines so we can focus on what’s most important—educating all children!


STRONGLY SUPPORT 2022 Model Policy in the name of protecting FEMALE and PARENTAL rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

This common sense policy not only protects and preserves young FEMALE girls' rights, it also tells them that their safety, privacy and opportunities are MORE IMPORTANT than the FEELINGS of biological males. For safety reasons, biological males should NEVER be allowed in biological females' private spaces (restrooms, locker rooms). For fairness reasons, biological males should NEVER be allowed to compete against female athletes.

To address the safety and opportunity of transgender youth, schools can easily incorporate transgender and/or gender-neutral restrooms, locker rooms, and athletic programs. This does not have to be about trans vs female rights. It can protect and respect BOTH.

This 2022 policy also restores parental rights as enshrined in the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which protects the fundamental right of parents to direct the care, upbringing, and education of their children.


Support! Telling These Children Lies Is What’s Harming Them! Cannot Change Your Gender!! Impossible!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Find out what is really going on in their lives, instead of glamorizing this dark and destructive path!! That is, if you really cared, as you claim. </p>


Don’t change current lgbt-friendly policy

<!DOCTYPE html>

The current lgbt-friendly policy is great and should not be changed.

It is a model for other states. Alexandria wants this policy for its students.

The changes Gov. Youngkin is proposing would take control away from local schools parents and taxpayers like me and concentrate it in the hands of the governor and his cronies


Transgenderism is a mental health problem.

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Don't bring your transgender problem to school.   Get some help.  </p>


Siding with trans kids SAVES LIVES

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Imagine not being allowed to exist. Helping trans kids literally saves lives. Stand with them and save a life. </p>


LGBTQ supports this change

<!DOCTYPE html>

As a parent and a member of the LGBTQ community, I support this change. Secrets should not be help from parents by teachers and faculties. I trust my ability to parent over that of my child's teachers.


Oppose draft model policy on transgender students

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I strongly oppose the draft policy that is rooted in transphobia and harms trans and non-binary kids. It also puts teachers in an untenable situation, requiring them to forcibly out students to their parents against their will. They are already under enough pressure w/o posing this additional burden. Please focus on more pressing issues such as inflation and cost of living. </p>


Heartless use of children

<!DOCTYPE html>

Another example of a power hungry politician using children to garner votes. Youngkin is the worst kind as he tries to have it both ways. It’s up to all of us to promote the best and kindest of human behavior not the hateful motivation of a few. Let’s protect our kids from these demons!


Protect our vulnerable trans children

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Please protect our children from vicious targeting. Children deserve to grow and express themselves by their chosen name and pronouns. </p>


Support parental rights

<!DOCTYPE html>

I support this legislation. Lets concentrate on education not wokeism.


Standing Up for Governor Youngkin

<!DOCTYPE html>

I am proud to say that I voted for the Governor. He is doing exactly what he said he would do if elected. He is standing up to Wokeness and involving interested parents in the education of their children. Our concern should be with the declining quality of our public education system rather than bathroom/locker room usage. As Americans we are all endowed by God with the SAME Rights regardless of sex, ethnicity, and whatever the latest woke hot button is. I would venture to guess that less than 2% of our public schools could realistically identify as transgender. The entire public school system cannot be changed to accommodate so few. How much time does a school attendee spend in bathroom and/or locker room anyway? Governor Youngkin is a bastion of common sense. Hopefully, this is a “baby step” towards getting our Commonwealth and our Country on the right track again


You don't get to change the english language

<!DOCTYPE html>

I don't even understand how you would call one person a they or them. Ultran left wingers always have to push the envelope. This isn't about gender identity. It is about forcing something on you and making you feel uncomfortable. It is about control and shock value. Leave the children of our society out of your stupid games.


Youngkin and his followers want to terrorize trans people

<!DOCTYPE html>

Glenn Youngkin wants to spread hate to anyone who doesn't share his ideologies, and for some reason he has chosen to target transgender people who have always been a targeted group along with other LGBTQ+ people. There have been thousands of students in protest towards his hate filled policies regarding trans kids. It is straight up bigotry.


Strongly oppose! Protect trans kids!

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p> These proposed model policies are contrary to state law and will be extremely harmful to transgender and nonbinary kids. Protect trans and nonbinary kids. RESCIND these model policies. </p>


Strongly Support Gov Youngkin's reformed Model Policies for Transgender Students

Edward McGovern
              / Ed McGovern

<!DOCTYPE html>

The most important aspect of the reformed Model Policy is safety for everyone.  Ralph Northam allowing males into Girls spaces led to sexual assaults.  I do not believe the public has been informed on all assaults.  Suicides are higher for everyone; and significantly higher for Trans teenagers since they started getting help from the "gifted 10%".  It has never been a good idea to deny reality.

Public Schools need to represent as broad a spectrum as possible.  There are a wide range of views on addressing Gender Identity.  The reformed Model policies allows for diverse views and discourse.

This issue is a key Civics lesson.  Forced speech is unconstitutional.  Allowing an 8-year old to dictate what a teacher could and couldn't say was a bad idea.  Taking power from National Union bosses is great.  Taking control from classroom teachers was not.


Support but CPS should be involved for Valid Domestic Abuse concerns

<!DOCTYPE html>

Parents/guardians should have the right to know if their child(ren) are going through this type of mental crisis. Children often speak in hyperbole thinking their parents will harm them if they do not agree or are disappointed in their actions/behavior. Majority of the children would not have any harm to them by their family. Let’s remember, adolescents and teens have developing brains, not mature brains. They are easily influenced, impulsive, take risks, do not understand consequences, etc. Children’s parents should be allowed the opportunity to have discussions with their child about what they are going through & get the family and individual counseling they need to do what is best for their mental health and overall well-being. If there is a true concern for the child’s safety, the proper school authorities have a duty and obligation much like healthcare providers to report abuse to social services/CPS. So, I agree parents ultimately should be notified but there should be protocols in place to handle domestic abuse concerns for students who have a valid fear for their safety.


YOU

Former student, now teacher, still Transgender

<!DOCTYPE html>

 you Youngkin.  . You.  As a former student who was bullied, had people stalk me to my home, throw trash at me, threaten to kill me, all for being transgender,  you.  I will not follow your new  laws, and other teachers stand with me.  I will not put my students in the same danger I faced as a teen.  If I had not been able to transition, I would be dead, just like your political career is going to be.  I will continue to stand by my students and protect their rights to safety, just as every other cisgender student receives.


Not sure what the issue is...FULLY SUPPORT

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>"...school leaders work to ensure that all students have an opportunity to receive a high-quality education."  Yes.  Get the schools, school boards, and VA DoE out of the business of legislating values and get back to education.  Fully support the proposed change to re-focus on schools' mandate to...TEACH FACTS.  Oh, and keep biological males out of girls' locker rooms, rest rooms, and sports (and vice-versa).  Fair and safe is fair and safe.</p>


REPUBLICANS ARE TERRORISTS. OPPOSE FASCISM.


This policy would harm the most vulnerable children- strongly oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

This proposal would harm the most vulnerable population of children, who already have the highest risk of suicide. If you care about the lives of children, please do not do this. If this policy is passed, trans children will have less support, less safety, and many will lose their lives by suicide or through trauma-related diseases such as anorexia or substance use disorder that they will turn to in order to cope. This policy will directly lead to children being at higher risk for all of these things, as well as increase the likelihood of abuse against them by forcibly outing them to potentially hostile families. Again, if you truly care about children, please don't do this.


ALL YOUNGKIN SUPPORTERS ARE NAZIS


Oppose this measure

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>I strongly oppose this. Children deserve our protection, especially those that are the least protected. Trans kids need to be protected, taken seriously, and supported. This bill doesn’t not support anything other than for Youngkin and the republican party’s political gain.  If you really are pro-life, then act like it. Put resources and support systems in place for people who are alive now to survive and flourish. That way we can secure and take care of the future generations. It is not morally okay to play with the lives and rights of others. We are all human belongs and need to treat and respect each other as such. </p>


Just because you don't understand doesn't mean we shouldn't protect Trans and LGBTQ+ Youth - OPPOSE

<!DOCTYPE html>

I am deeply concerned with the recent trend to overturn protections put in place for LGBTQ + Teens Youth.  You are putting lives on the line for petty politics, extremist votes and religious intolerance with such moves.  How can you possibly look a child in the eye disregarding their beliefs for your own and knowing they can't protect and be their true self with such legislative changes.  These protections are fundamental rights of a child who should feel safe, protected and have the ability to be their true self without fear.

I firmly oppose this legislation that strips away protection and our children's rights away from and puts them in harms way.


REPUBLICANS ARE TERRORISTS. OPPOSE NAZIS


I support the Governor - SCHOOLS

<!DOCTYPE html>

I am strongly in support of PARENTS having the responsibility for their children - not the schools, not the principals, not the teachers, not the adminstrators, not the WOKE spokesmen/women/persons.  I routinely attend our local school board meetings - even though my own children are now adults with children of their own.  I attend to speak for my grandson, whose parents are afraid to attend for fear of reprisals against their son.  And this is not uncommon in our present environment.  We have deputies at every meeting - ready to toss any parent/grandparent/adult out if they raise their voices . . . . . and that is pathetic.  Since when do we use our local law enforcement to SILENCE voters?

Keep up the good work, sir.  Thank you for standing up for our children and their parents/grandparents and the rest of our community.

Respectfully,

Sandi Gauthier

USN Captain, Retired


Transgenderism is tyranny by the minority.   (Less than 1%)

<!DOCTYPE html>

Neither tyranny nor insanity is a right.


OPPOSE FASCISM. ALL REPUBLICANS ARE TERRORISTS.


<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Youngkin resign </p>


Strongly Oppose Discrimination Against Transgender Children

<!DOCTYPE html>

I strongly oppose the proposed policy changes in reference to transgender students. Children should not suffer because of the prejudices of adults. These changes also distract from the learning process.


PROTECT TRANS KIDS!!!

<!DOCTYPE html>

hi. most of you don’t know me and that’s ok. I’m up here right now to talk about glenn youngkin’s restrictive, dumba*s laws. i grew up in a home and church that said you had to be free of sin, that homosexuality and being transgender is going against nature. well, screw that!

youngkin is just trying to get power by taking away our own idenity- pronouns, names, and appearance. what’s next? it’s banned to feel like you? He’s calling us the imposters, but really it’s him.

And-we’re only human. We’re bound to change, we can’t live with their perfect norms. This is the present. This is now! we don’t have to remain in the past and they need to know that. nobody is perfect and it’s ok to change. they can’t take away our right to life, liberty, or the pursuit of happiness.

And our parents? They said they've been through this. But they haven’t. while my parents agree the laws are stupid, they say they deserve to know what’s going on with us. Do they? Us teens are very wobbly with trust.  they didn’t have to go through the pandemic as teens or virtual learning, the time were were torn apart and glued together with dried-up glue.

many people i know, including me, have changed their name, style, hair, and pronouns to make themselves feel free in the oppressive world we live in. and he wants to take away everything we’ve worked for-  Our freedom, our life. i have a friend. he is trans and proud to be this way. and if these new laws pass, then he’ll be forced to use she/her pronouns and his deadname. SO many people will go back to the enforcement, away from where they called home. and forced to be outed to the world, their families?

no.

this should not be the state we live in, in fear of being forced back to the place we worked so hard to get out of


Fully support Gov. Youngkin

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Any policy that prevents gov’t schools from operating independent of parents is something to be supported. </p>


Protect our daughter’s!! Do not allow biological boys in locker rooms or girl’s sports.


Support

<!DOCTYPE html>

Don’t allow biological boys in girl’s locker rooms or in girl’s sports.. protect our daughters… how about more mental health resources!


oppose!

<!DOCTYPE html>

trans kids deserve to feel safe. this policy is an attack on children. rethink.


Strongly Oppose Fascist Youngkins disgusting policies

<!DOCTYPE html>

Resign. You’re a disgrace.


ONLY education in our schools!!! Fully support Governor Youngkin!

<!DOCTYPE html>

Only education.  We have our hands full with that!  Can’t deal with these “special” problems…


Strongly oppose

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>As a former teacher and current mental health professional I strongly oppose the proposal put forth. </p>


Protect our kids

<!DOCTYPE html>

first and foremost this policy is not supported by evidence, which is required by virginia law. secondly it puts our children in danger. students, trans students included, have a right to feel safe in their school and this policy takes that away from them. requiring teachers out students to their parents may put them at a huge risk for being harmed, and take away their safe space away from home. furthermore allowing students to be opted out of counseling takes away their support at school, when it is especially important that they have access to it. the suicide rate amongst trans students is significantly higher as is (as reported by the cdc and aap) and these policies further solidify that.

their lives are in your hands, handle with care. trans inclusivity saves lives.


Agreement with new policy.

<!DOCTYPE html>

I believe that the "Transgender" learning awareness has it's roots in "Politics"(and or a  specific political ideology), and is not rooted in education. There is little or no science behind "Gender confusion", but one can be molded and pressured and manipulated into a state of confusion. Both men and women can display masculine or feminine traits without "labeling" or "marginalizing" them to playing a role that they were never intended to play!

Also, one of the greatest strengths of any society or nation rests in the strength of the family. Since "Transgender studies" are NOT English, Math, History, Reading, Science or other Elective subjects. And since "Education" is still funded by the Public; my thought is Educators need a lot more input from the people who are paying their salaries before they so radically change course material.

I'm not suggesting that every time something new is added to the school's curriculum you ask for a vote! But, in this case and other's like it.....public input! And, instead of just one pervasive viewpoint, also offer an alternative point of view. So, we teach our children how to think, and not just parrot a particular point of view!

Jim Witkower


girls should not have boys in bathroom

<!DOCTYPE html>

Who be all these people that think its ok to have boys in girls bathrooms? do you actually even have kids? i dont believe this is real


Opposed: Pro life means reducing childhood and teenage suicide

<!DOCTYPE html>

https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/Trans-Suicide-Summary-Sep-2021.pdf

Please make an evidence based decision to support the future of Virginia. Gender affirmative laws will reduce depression and suicide in these children and teens. Reduction in these (besides saving precious lives) also reduce the burden on the state for mental health resources. Ask yourself who is this benefiting and who is this harming? If the answer is children are being harmed- why would you support that law? It’s an evil stance. How do you want to save unborn children but not the ones already here living full lives. Lives that will be made more difficult for no reason other than bigotry. Why are you so obsessed with trans people? They aren’t in your bed or your relationship. So leave them alone.


Strongly support

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>Strongly support </p>


PROTECT TRANS KIDS RIGHTS

<!DOCTYPE html>

<p>These policies directly harm our Virginia youth. It is an inane action to install them. Protect our children’s lives </p>


2022 policy model proposal

<!DOCTYPE html>

Strongly support! Encourage parental involvement-keep private parts/private matters PRIVATE. Focus on learning!! 2022 VA school policy model proposal


SUPPORT! 12 Year Old Can Decide To Never Have Children, But 18 Y.O. Can’t Understand Student Loans?

<!DOCTYPE html>

Quit coaching and grooming the children!! It’s absolutely WRONG!!!!